Published May 25th, 2023 by HQ
Mystery, Historical Fiction, Historical Mystery, Romance Novel, Lesbian Literature
I’m finally sharing my review for the mesmerising Vita and the Birds, which is one of my favourite books this year. Thank you to HQ Stories for my gifted ARC.
*********
SYNOPSIS:
A haunting mystery for fans of Eve Chase, Kate Morton and Kate Mosse.
‘A poignant page-turning story, beautifully written’ Leonora Nattrass, author of Blue Water
’Hugely evocative and beautifully written’ Anna Mazzola, author of The Clockwork Girl
‘A thoroughly compelling mystery meets a poignant love story, all wrapped up in beautifully lyrical writing’ Frances Quinn, author of The Smallest Man
‘A beguiling mystery from a gifted storyteller’ Louise Fein, author of People Like Us
1938: Lady Vita Goldsborough lives in the menacing shadow of her controlling older brother, Aubrey. But when she meets local artist Dodie Blakeney, the two women form a close bond, and Vita finally glimpses a chance to be free.
1997: Following the death of her mother, Eve Blakeney returns to the coast where she spent childhood summers with her beloved grandmother, Dodie. Eve hopes that the visit will help make sense of her grief. The last thing she expects to find is a bundle of letters that hint at the heart-breaking story of Dodie’s relationship with a woman named Vita, and a shattering secret that echoes through the decades.
What she discovers will overturn everything she thought she knew about her family – and change her life forever.
‘Luminous and captivating … Polly Crosby’s shimmering writing veils a dark hint of the gothic’ Kate Griffin, author of Fyneshade
********
MY REVIEW:
“Rumours had always abounded. Of marsh spirits and witches, of people gone mad. Of sucking mud and drowning men and bog bodies being preserved in peat. It was an ancient place, the reed field where the cathedral stood, dangerous long before the glass house was ever built.”
Luminous, mesmerising, and hauntingly atmospheric, Vita and the Birds tells the story of two women whose lives are inextricably linked by decades-old secrets.
1938. Lady Vita Goldsborough lives an isolated and lonely life at the mercy of her cruel and controlling older brother, Audrey. But a chance meeting with local artist Dodie changes everything, and when the two become close Vita glimpses a possible chance of freedom.
1997. Eve Blakeney returns to the house on the coast where she spent her childhood summers to try and come to terms with her grief after her mother’s death. While there, Eve unexpectedly finds clues to a secret that will change everything she believed about her family.
Polly Crosby merges historical fiction and compelling mystery with eerie gothic elements and a dash of romance to create an extraordinary story that I never wanted to end. She took my breath away with her atmospheric, unnerving, and evocative prose, painting a picture with words that made me feel like I’d tumbled into the story like Alice tumbled into the rabbit hole. Themes of mental health, coercive control, friendship, desire, and female empowerment and agency are explored as Crosby peels away the layers of this complex mystery piece by piece. I was hypnotised and completely in her thrall; torn between a need to devour the book whole and wanting to read it forever..
“But the thing that had given me the most purpose, was the mystery of my family, caught up in the birdcage and the letters and the sketchbooks. And all of it, I realised, was linked to the Cathedral of the Marshes, the secrets entwined together like the trailing vines that grew inside it.”
Rumours of madness and murder have surrounded the Goldsborough family for decades, and the Cathedral of the Marshes – built by Aubrey Goldsborough in the 1920s – is the local haunted house that teenagers dare each other to enter. The Goldsboroughs and the cathedral are inextricably linked to the Blakeney family through the friendship between Vita and Dodie, as well as the secret they shared. Told in dual timelines, we follow Vita and Dodie as their friendship blossoms in the past, while in the present her granddaughter begins to unveil the truth that will change everything. I have to mention that I really enjoyed the author’s decision to set this in the 90s as it was a nostalgia-fest for me and I loved being transported back to what feels like a simpler time.
The characters are all richly drawn and compelling, but the narrators both have a particular charisma that makes you root for them and care what happens to them. And while on the surface they couldn’t be more different – Vita is rich while Eve doesn’t have two pennies to rub together – we soon discover they have more in common than we thought. They are both trapped in cages just like Vita’s beloved birds. Vita’s cage is made from bars created by her cruel, vicious, and controlling older brother, Audrey, while Eve’s is made inside her own mind as she struggles with her mental health. But one of the most important ‘characters’ in this book isn’t a person. The Cathedral of the Marshes is at the heart of this story. Most of the time it looms menacing, dark and mysterious in the shadows, but there are times it is a sanctuary and an escape. It is a place long surrounded by local folklore and rumours of murders and missing children. And it’s this folklore, along with the vivid descriptions of the building and the feelings it conjures, that combine to make it feel alive; a sinister presence that permeates every page.
Lush, hypnotic, poignant, and unsettling, this gorgeously gothic story consumed me. An absolute masterpiece that you won’t forget.
Rating: ✮✮✮✮✮
********
MEET THE AUTHOR:
Polly grew up on the Suffolk coast, and now lives in the heart of Norfolk with her husband and son, and her very loud and much loved rescue Oriental cat, Dali. She is passionate about nature, and her writing is very much inspired by the local landscape.
After a whirlwind of a year which saw Polly receive writing scholarships from both Curtis Brown Creative and The University of East Anglia’s MA in Creative Writing, she went on to be runner up in the Bridport Prize’s Peggy Chapman Andrews Award for a First Novel.
Polly’s debut novel, The Illustrated Child, was snapped up by HarperCollins HQ in the UK in a 48 hour pre-empt, and a few days later by HarperCollins Park Row Books in North America. Her second novel, The Unravelling, came out the following year.
Vita & the Birds, her third novel, is out in May.
********
BUY THE BOOK:
Waterstones* | Amazon* | Bookshop.org*
********
Thanks for reading Bibliophiles xxxx
*These purchase links are affiiate links
Emma's Biblio Treasures 
