Published October 31st, 2023 by Tor
Gothic Fiction, Contemporary Fantasy, Fairy Tale, Mythology, Dark Fantasy
Welcome to my review for the eerie and unsettling gothic fantasy, Starling House, which was the October Reese’s Book Club pick. Thank you to Tor and Black Crow PR for my copies of the book.
*********
SYNOPSIS:
A Reese Witherspoon Book Club Pick
‘Alix E. Harrow is an exceptional, undeniable talent’ – Olivie Blake, author of The Atlas Six
Step into Starling House – if you dare . . . Alix E. Harrow reimagines Beauty and the Beast in this gorgeously modern Gothic fantasy, perfect for fans of V.E. Schwab and Naomi Novik.
Nobody in Eden remembers when Starling House was built. But the town agrees it’s best to let this ill-omened mansion – and its last lonely heir – go to hell. Stories of the house’s bad luck, like good china, have been passed down the generations.
Opal knows better than to mess with haunted houses, or brooding men. But when an opportunity to work there arises, the money might get her brother out of Eden. Starling House is uncanny and full of secrets – just like Arthur, its heir. It also feels strangely, dangerously, like something she’s never had: a home. Yet Opal isn’t the only one interested in the horrors and the wonders that lie buried beneath it.
Sinister forces converge on Eden – and Opal realizes that if she wants a home, she’ll have to fight for it. Even if it involves digging up her family’s ugly past to achieve a better future. She’ll have to go down, deep down beneath Starling House, to claw her way back to the light . . .
This is a romantic and spellbinding Gothic fairytale from Hugo, Nebula and Locus Award-shortlisted Alix E. Harrow.
‘Starling House is Alix E. Harrow’s greatest work yet’ – Ava Reid, author of Juniper and Thorn
********
MY REVIEW:
“Dreams are just like stray cats. If you don’t feed them they get lean and clever and sharp-clawed, and come for the jugular when you least expect it.”
Starling House is the ‘haunted house’ that Eden’s residents avoid. Stories about curses, bad luck and even murder have been passed down for generations. Opal knows she should stay away from the foreboding, dilapidated mansion, but there’s something drawing her to it. And when she’s offered a job by Arthur, its strange and mysterious heir, the offer is too good to resist; a chance to finally save enough money to get her brother, Jasper, out of this small town and into a better life. But there’s a darkness to Arthur Starling and his house, something dangerous that makes Opal wonder if the stories might be true after all…
Unsettling, eerie and forbidding, Starling House is a gorgeous dark gothic fantasy filled with magic, monsters, secrets and suspicion. In her beautifully written and alluring reimagining of Beauty and the Beast Alix E. Harrow has crafted a phantasmagoria of mystery, fantasy and horror that is impossible to resist. Much like the eponymous house, it pulls you in and transports you to another world, holding you under its spell until the last page. There are many things I loved about Ms. Harrow’s writing but I particularly enjoyed how she had Opal talk directly to the reader so you feel like you’re part of an intimate conversation rather than reading fiction. I also loved that she included footnotes throughout the book that made it seem like we’re reading an account of actual events and playing into making the story so believable. I had to keep reminding myself that all of this was fiction and the product of an author’s evocative imagination.
“I should probably be freaked out—this place is eerie and endless, a rotting labyrinth—but mostly I just feel sorry for it. Starling House makes me think of an underfed pet or a broken doll, a thing unloved by the person who promised to love them best.”
The story is told by two narrators: Opal and Arthur. Opal is the underdog, a down-on-her-luck orphan caring for her younger brother who is scraping together every penny to survive. Spiky, fierce and spirited, you can’t help cheering her on, even as she does things you don’t approve of. After all, she’s simply trying to survive. Arthur, the heir and Warden of Starling House, takes more warming up to. Eccentric, cryptic and strange, he’s creepy at first but Harrow gives this reclusive character a beating heart, making the beast human and someone we feared into someone we care about. It’s an irresistible redemption tale that is perfectly executed. And while they may appear to be vastly different, they actually have a lot in common: they are both orphans who people of the town gossip about, look down on and are suspicious of, and they are both filled with a sense of duty: Opal to her brother, Jasper, and Arthur as Warden of Starling House. I loved watching their stories unfold and their relationship grow. By the end I was rooting for them both and hoping for a happy ending.
“The House wants her, and the House is stubborn… He doesn’t know why it would want her of all people: A freckled scarecrow of a girl with crooked teeth and holes in the knees of her jeans, entirely unremarkable except for the steel in her eyes. And perhaps for the way she stood her ground against him. He is a ghost, a rumor, a story whispered after the children have gone to bed, and she was cold and hurt, all alone in the rising dark—and yet she hadn’t run from him until he told her to. The House has always had a taste for the brave ones.”
Starling House is more than a house. It’s a living, breathing entity and an important character in the book. When you step over its threshold you’re transported to another world. One that is dark, terrifying and secretive. Where there is magic, monsters and mythical creatures. But there’s so much more; the house seems to have a consciousness, feelings, a heartbeat. Its darkness is seductive and it pulls you in, just like it drew Opal to its gates. And while this world is filled with unbelievable things, Harrow makes it feel totally believable as she combines the perfect amount of the magical, supernatural and mythical with reality that makes us buy into its existence and lose ourselves inside it.
“Small towns are supposed to be cozy and friendly, like perfect little snow globes, but me and Jasper have always been kept on the other side of the glass.”
The town of Eden is also very important to the story. This small town lives and breathes legend. Everyone and everything is cursed and the residents simply turn a blind eye. They also turn a blind eye to prejudice and suffering, topics that are explored throughout the book and we see examples of in both narrators’ lives. There is also an overwhelming feeling of claustrophobia that comes from this small-town setting and Starling House, adding to the tense and sinister air that hovers over every page.
Darkly atmospheric, haunting, dreamlike and bewitching, this mesmerising gothic fantasy is a must read.
Rating: ✮✮✮✮.5
********
MEET THE AUTHOR:
Alix E. Harrow is the NYT-bestselling author of The Ten Thousand Doors of January, The Once and Future Witches, Starling House, and various short fiction, including a duology of retold fairy tales (A Spindle Splintered and A Mirror Mended). Her work has won a Hugo and a British Fantasy Award, and been shortlisted for the Nebula, World Fantasy, Locus, Southern Book Prize, and Goodreads Choice awards.
She’s from Kentucky, but now lives in Charlottesville, Virginia with her husband and their two semi-feral kids.
********
BUY THE BOOK
Waterstones* | Bookshop.org*| Amazon*
********
Thanks for reading Bibliophiles xxx
*These purchase links are affiliate links
Emma's Biblio Treasures 